Equally satisfying is the fact that for the first time, my generation has started taking active interest in politics. We are no longer indifferent. We are debating on key issues. Issues like malnourishment in a state and the economic growth under a chief minister. We are talking about the transparency in a party and the merit of candidates. We want to hear the opinion of PM nominees on key issues before we cast our vote. For the first time we are monitoring the steps taken by a CM during the first two weeks at office. This I think is the biggest success of both NaMo and Kejriwal. These are the signs of a healthy democracy.
Now let me mention a few areas which I find concerning. I will exclude all the issues which are already being discussed in the mainstream media. I will also avoid commenting on the policies which were announced post the results of Delhi assembly elections.
1) Target Audience: Who is Aam Aadmi?
The AAP team has repeatedly focussed on the fact that unlike other parties, they are here to serve the common man, the aam aadmi. But who is a aam aadmi? From the public statements of party leaders, it seems almost everyone is an aam aadmi. From riksha waala to doctor. From an IT engineer in Bangalore to a professor in Jaipur. AAP's definition of aam aadmi includes everyone whether BPL person or someone earning 2 lacs per month.
This surely does not look like a niche to me. From my experience of talking to VCs and entrepreneurs, I can say one thing for sure: If you say that you will cater to a segment which is unserved to by your competitors and in the same breath you say that your target audience is 95% of all users, you will be kicked out of the meeting room within five minutes.
Why does not the party simply say that it aims to serve all Indians equally instead of focussing on the word 'Aam Aadmi'. Isn't this misleading.
Though I can understand Kejriwal's point that other parties are corrupt and criminals, I know for sure that they can go to any extend to get votes. I fail to understand Kejriwal's claim that these vote thirsty parties are intentionally ignoring 95% of the voters. Does not make sense.
(On a lighter note, I find it strange that the Shobha Des and Mayawatis of the world have not called Kejriwal sexist yet. What about the Aam Aurat? Why is she excluded from the party name)
2) Merit: What Are The Metrics?
As a transparent and democratic party, shouldn't there be more details regarding the metric for selecting its candidates? Unlike AAP, other parties have been in existence for years. There is supposedly a system in other parties where either family members of prominent leaders or businessmen with spare money to put into campaigning or party workers who over the years show there mettle in politics are given the ticket from specific constituencies.
![]() |
Tata Tea - Neta ke job ka qualification |
The metric made public has been that we will give ticket to honest people who want to serve the country. Both these parameters are not only subjective, but also have a ceiling. One can only be 100% honest, not more than that. I am sure that the party would claim that all its members are 100% honest. So how do you choose from so many honest people?
Though you can personally talk to some shortlisted people and understand their past work, But with the loksabha nomination form available online, there are bound to be many applicants. How would AAP do the first screening? CGPA cutoff? GMAT score? Aptitude test?
Aptitude test would be good start considering we would never want to have an honest yet foolish person leading our constituency or state or nation.
3) Inclusion vs Autocracy
I love the AAP agenda of inclusion in politics. It sounds good that everyone will get a chance to represent his/her people. It also sounds good that all party decisions will be taken in a democratic way keeping the opinions of key people in mind. But somehow this promise contradicts what I see on the AAP membership form and on the loksabha nomination form.
Take this for example:
![]() |
Screen shot of clauses in the AAP membership form |
What if I am an honest and patriotic citizen of India who wants to see his country grow, but I believe in some cause which conflicts with the Party objectives and want to continue working towards that cause? Am I not allowed to join AAP?
Or take this for example:
![]() |
Screen shot of clauses in the AAP Loksabha nomination form |
What if I sincerely believe that acquiring land for the greater good of the society is a necessary evil and do not not want to bring laws which can impact this process? Should I forget about joining AAP and instead join the corrupt parties?
How is this democratic in any way. A bunch of you guys have defined the party ideology and now new people will be added to that bunch only if they agree to your ideology. How will the party have any meaningful internal debate in future if everyone in the party has exactly the same ideology. Are you not creating too much selection bias? Stuff your party with people who have all left of centre views?
![]() |
Screen shot of clauses in the AAP membership form |
The one above too is debatable. What if someone who has been convicted of a crime, served his sentence and is now a changed man. Is he not allowed to participate in your 'Aam' movement. Even after serving his sentence, he has lost his democratic rights?
4) AAP Supporters: What Is Your Stance?
I wrote a blog post long back where I tried to give my analysis of NaMo as prime ministerial candidate. Soon the NaMo and Congress fan brigade started abusing it though I was being as neutral as possible. This is exactly what pisses the neutral people off who are trying to have a healthy debate. Are AAP fans doing the exact same thing now?
Whenever anyone criticizes AAP, the fans would start giving example of other parties and how they are worse. That is meaningless. We have already agreed that there are problems with the existing political system and AAP gives us hope that they will be different from the existing players. So when someone says that AAP is doing politics of appeasement, I do not expect a counter argument that even others are doing it.
Also, if AAP stands for aam aadmi and making them our representative, why are we rejoicing when CEOs of investment banks, editors from paid media, owners of companies are joining AAP? How are these people different? Every party has industrialists and journalists as its members. Does it mean anything?
5) Means vs Ends
Kejriwal wanted to get the Lokpal bill passed. He also wanted to implement some other policies which he believed in. I will not start a debate about those policies, but I find it commendable that he seeks power to introduce his policies. It is a good stance.
But the AAP team must understand that we support them because they seek power only to implement their policies. If it starts looking as if AAP is implementing certain policies, just to get in power, then the cycle is reversed.
The clarity of means vs ends needs to remain intact. AAP is here to serve the nation, not to win elections.
very nicely put up !
ReplyDeleteThanks Goel..
ReplyDeleteGreat "AAM AADMI" review... CGPA?GMAT?.......hilarious :)
ReplyDeleteHaha..Thanks Sujay..
ReplyDeleteNukul..well written and good points raised..
ReplyDeleteBhai.. dil jeet liya.. :)
ReplyDeleteI am about to take the GMAT too and I know how hard the test can be. I have been preparing myself by taking an online GMAT prep course to help me get ready. It has been very beneficial to me so far, so I am hoping I can pass the real thing. Good luck to you
ReplyDeleteAWA GMAT Essay
Education Loan is provided by banks and financial organization and covers fee for all years, which is normally paid out to the college/institute directly by the bank.
ReplyDeletePractice questions can help familiarize with the GMAT, but in the end, we need to be physically and mentally ready in order to answer the questions without any doubt.
ReplyDeleteielts speaking questions
Freelance Best Makeup & Hair Artist in Jaipur with huge experience and Specialization in Bridal and Wedding Makeup,Celebrity Makeup,Professional Makeup,Creative Makeup,Bollywood Makeup..
ReplyDeleteFiza Makeup Academy
Fiza Makeup and Hair Artist
Wedding Makeup Artist in jaipur
Bridal Makeup Artist in jaipur
Professional Makeup Artist in jaipur
Hair and Makeup Artist in jaipur
Celebrity Makeup Artist in jaipur
Creative Makeup Artist in jaipur
Bollywood Makeup Artist in jaipur
Character Makeup Artist in jaipur
Fiza Makeup Academy Rajasthan
Shree Ram Techno Solutions Provides CCTV Camera, Security Camera, Wireless Security, Attendance System, Access Control System, DVR, NVR, Spy Camera, Fire Alarm, Security Alarm, PCI, IP Network Camera, Dome Camera, IR Camera, CCTV, Camera Price, HIKVISION, SCATI, Time Machine
ReplyDeleteCCTV CAmera in jaipur at Rajasthan
Home security system in jaipur
Wireless Home Security System in jaipur
Realtime attendance machine in jaipur
cctv camera dealer in jaipur
Hikvision DVR in jaipur at Rajasthan
security system solutions in jaipur
CBSE Board 10th Compartment Result 2017
ReplyDeleteCBSE Board 12th Compartment Result 2017
Kalyani University Routine 2018
ReplyDeleteTripura Board Madhyamim Date Sheet 2018
Tripura Board HS Date Sheet 2018
Telangana SSC Date Sheet 2018
Telanagana Intermediate Date Sheet 2018
JKBOSE 10th Date Sheet
ReplyDeleteHSC Exam Routine BD
SSLC Time Table
SSC Exam Routine BD
Intermediate Time Table
Krishna University Result 2018
ReplyDeleteDravidian University Result 2018
GNDU Result 2018
Punjab University Result 2018
ANU Result 2018
Andhra University Result 2018
SGGU Result 2018
Saurashtra University Result 2018
Sardar Patel Uniersity Result 2018
MSU Baroda Result 2018
boardexamresults2018.in
ReplyDeleteup assistant teacher syllabus 2017
ibpscutoffmarks.in
rrb ajmer alp technician recruitment 2017
IPPS Recruitment 2018
ReplyDeleteCISF Recrutiment 2018
KVS Recruitment 2018
TNPSC Recruitment 2018
KVK Recruitment 2018
OMC Recrutiment 2018
MPEZ Recruitment 2018
FCI Uttarakhand Recruitment 2018
BMRCL Recruitment 2018
Odisha CHSE Date Sheet 2018
ReplyDeleteLNMU Date Sheet 2018
Kota University Date Sheet 2018
Allahabad University Date Sheet 2018
RMLAU Time Table 2018
MAHA Board HSC Date Sheet 2018
MAHA Board SSC Date Sheet 2018
Odisha Board HSC Date Sheet 2018
HQ Southern Command Pune Tradesman Vacancy 2018
ReplyDeleteThanks mate for the post it is very helpful uiic vacancy 2018
ReplyDeleteExcellent article. Very interesting to read. I really love to read such a nice article. Thanks! keep rocking.
ReplyDeleteFire Alarm Security System
It is the kind of information I have been trying to find. Thank you for writing this information. It has proved utmost beneficial for me. tools for brand yourself
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI like this blog its a master peace ! Glad I observed this on google . branding agency san francisco
ReplyDeleteYou have some seriously important information written here. Great job and keep posting terrific stuff. branding san francisco
ReplyDeleteColleagues at work are mentioning this brand naming agency. Has anyone had any experiences with them before? If so, do you recommend?
ReplyDeleteThere is noticeably big money comprehend this. I assume you made particular nice points in functions also. branding companies in los angeles
ReplyDeleteTogether with Visit Article content Page Syndication Provider, it is possible to move deeper together with faster rather than you might have truly dreamed with regards to your alternatives on-line. top branding agencies los angeles
ReplyDeleteWe still cannot quite think that I could truthfully often be those types of checking important points entirely on your blog post. My children and so i are sincerely thankful for one’s generosity too as for giving me possibility pursue our chosen profession path. Information you information I received with your web-site. brand identity los angeles
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing this information. I really like your blog post very much. You have really shared a informative and interesting blog post with people.. brand names on sale
ReplyDeletebuy youtube views There are many different ways to buy games. Games are expensive however, so is there any solutions to making big savings when you buy games? In this article we will look at several different ways, and look at how you can make big savings.
ReplyDeleteIt’s really such nice information to get advantage from.
ReplyDeletebrand design agency
Play variants like double publicity and multi hand blackjack instantly. ITech Labs is a testing and certification lab for Online Gaming techniques, focusing on compliance, software program high quality, reporting and delivery. Having testing completed by iTech Labs 토토사이트 ensures that games and gaming techniques adjust to all related requirements, and that they're truthful, reliable and resilient.
ReplyDelete